The Value Equation in 2025 — How Consumers Define Value and How Restaurants Can Deliver It

Beverage Trends, Breakfast Trends, Consumer Insights, CPG & Retail, Foodservice, Global Flavors, Ingredient Trends, Innovation, Menu Trends, Pizza Trends, Restaurants, Sales Effectiveness

Stay informed on the latest food industry insights by subscribing to our newsletter.

Subscribe Now

Defining true value in foodservice in 2025 has become the tightrope every restaurant and retail operator is walking. Consumers are more selective than ever about where they spend, and value now sits just behind taste as the biggest driver of consumer dining behavior 2025, according to Datassential’s recent report, “The Value Equation.”

Gen X and Boomers lean hardest into value, but even younger diners are feeling the squeeze. Nearly one-third of consumers, especially Gen Z, put saving money at the top of their decision-making. Younger diners also place a premium on speed and convenience, pulling experience into the value conversation in a bigger way.

The shift becomes even clearer when you look at taste. In 2022, 65% of consumers said restaurant food tasted better than home cooking, according to the report. Today, that’s flipped — 53% say home-cooked meals taste better. Restaurants still win on convenience and experience, but flavor is no longer the guaranteed advantage it once was. Operators navigating restaurant pricing trends in 2025 can’t depend on taste alone. Value is now a full experience — not a single metric.

How Consumers Define Value — And Why It’s Evolving

When asked to define value, most consumers land on a Goldilocks approach: a good deal without sacrificing food quality or experience. Nearly two-thirds fall into this middle category, the report finds. About 20% prefer the very best meal, regardless of price. The final 15% — largely Gen Z and Millennials — define value purely as “the cheapest option.”

Even so, most consumers agree that a meal doesn’t need to be cheap to feel like good value. Over 80% say good service and a pleasant experience boost perceived value, and 74% say a meal can be a strong value even at a higher price. Value meals trends aren’t just about savings — they’re about emotional payoff.

What Drives Consumer Value Perceptions Today

Despite their stated priorities, consumers still behave in more price-sensitive ways. Nearly a third say price is the most important factor when choosing where to eat, and discounts remain the strongest motivator for dine-in and off-premise behavior. Value is emotional one minute and financial the next.

When consumers evaluate a menu item’s value, they focus on four factors: taste, price, portion size, and ingredient quality. That’s the structural backbone of menu value optimization. Younger diners skew price-first. Boomers lean toward portion stability, freshness, and flavor. And two in five consumers think that if something feels too cheap, there must be a quality tradeoff — creating a sweet spot operators can use strategically, according to Datassential.

Where Consumers Go for the Best Value

When value is the priority, fast food takes first place thanks to predictable pricing, combo structures, and strong fast food value perception. Home cooking lands second, followed by fast casual, grocery prepared foods, and then full-service restaurants. Grocery prepared foods have become a serious competitor in the food away from home trends landscape, offering convenience and affordability while sidestepping the perceived “restaurant tax.”

How Deals, Discounts, and Bundles Shape Behavior

Consumers are using savings tools, but not constantly. Sixty-two percent ordered a combo or value bundle in the past month, according to Datassential’s report. Fifty-five percent used a coupon or loyalty reward. Most used these only once or twice — not daily. Gen Z and Millennials are the biggest deal-seekers.

Across generations, the most appealing promotions are percentage-off discounts, combo meals, BOGO (“buy one get one free”) formats, and buy-more-save-more offers. Gen Z gravitates toward deals that increase quantity or add extras. Boomers want straightforward price savings. Operators who build promotions that reflect these sometimes divergent consumer preferences see the biggest lift.

What Operators Believe About Value — And Where They Struggle

When asking operators about their focus, value is equally urgent — and more complicated. According to Datassential’s report, ninety-two percent of operators say delivering value is a core priority. Eighty-three percent feel confident in their current menu pricing strategy, but most say it’s far harder than ever to maintain value perception without impacting margins.

Operators widely agree that diners are maxed out on price increases. Two-thirds say consumers care more about overall value than the number on the check. Nearly 60% believe diners look at service, environment, and experience — not just price — when evaluating value. Most operators believe the definition consumers connect with most is “high-quality food that’s worth the price.” Only 5% think customers want purely the cheapest option.

The Gap Between Consumer Preferences and Operator Strategies

Consumers theoretically say quality and experience define value — but their purchasing behavior still leans heavily on discounts. Meanwhile, operators view promotions as a secondary focus and tend to prioritize taste, quality, and service. That mismatch creates a gap: operators are reinforcing fundamentals while consumers are still motivated by simple, clear savings opportunities.

The Smartest Value Strategies for 2025 Menus

Nearly three-quarters of operators have introduced or relaunched value-focused strategies in the past six months, according to Datassential. The most common approaches are daily specials, combo meals, loyalty rewards, limited-time offers, happy hour deals, and free extras. These approaches work across menu trends because they pair craveable items with transparent pricing.

Operators say the key ingredients for successful value strategies are simple pricing, easy execution, and strong cross-utilization of ingredients. The easier it is for consumers to understand the offer, the faster they convert.

How Restaurants Can Optimize Value Without Hurting Margins

The operators winning on value follow a few clear principles.

Protect quality and flavor. Even if consumers say home cooking tastes better now, taste is still the top driver.
Use portion size intentionally — smaller portions must be offset by freshness, customization, or experience.
Simplify communication: clear pricing, clean menu language, and transparent deals make consumers feel confident.
Design flexible value vehicles like bundles, add-ons, and limited-time offers that appeal to current consumer preferences.
Invest in emotional value — hospitality, atmosphere, and consistency still matter.
Stay aware of grocery prepared foods as a rising competitor. Restaurants must demonstrate what they uniquely offer: flavor innovation, service, and a better overall dining experience.

The Bottom Line for 2025 — Value Isn’t Cheap, It’s Confidence

Value in 2025 isn’t about low prices — it’s about making consumers feel their money was well spent. Operators want to deliver strong value without sacrificing margins. Consumers want confidence. The brands that master transparency, quality, simple pricing, and craveable menu design will outperform competitors and stay ahead of the curve.

This information in this article comes from Datassential’s “The Value Equation” that’s available only for subscribers. For more information or to subscribe, visit this link.

For media inquiries, contact media@datassential.com.

Frequently Asked Questions About Restaurant Value

What does value mean to restaurant consumers in 2025?

Value in 2025 means finding the sweet spot between quality and price. According to Datassential, nearly two-thirds of consumers define value as getting a good deal without sacrificing food quality or the dining experience. While about 15% focus purely on finding the cheapest option (primarily Gen Z and Millennials), most diners want a balance. Over 80% agree that excellent service and a pleasant atmosphere increase perceived value, and 74% believe a meal can represent strong value even at a higher price point. Value has evolved beyond just low prices to encompass the entire dining experience.
Why is value more important to restaurant customers now than in previous years?

Value has become critical because consumer dining behavior has fundamentally shifted. Value now ranks just behind taste as the biggest driver of where people choose to eat. Nearly one-third of consumers, especially Gen Z, prioritize saving money above other factors (source: Datassential). The competitive landscape has changed too—in 2022, 65% of consumers believed restaurant food tasted better than home cooking, but by 2025, that flipped to 53% preferring home-cooked meals. With taste no longer a guaranteed restaurant advantage and economic pressures mounting, value has become the deciding factor for most dining decisions.
How do consumers decide if a restaurant meal is good value?

Consumers evaluate menu items based on four primary factors: taste, price, portion size, and ingredient quality. These elements form the structural foundation of how diners assess value. However, preferences vary by generation—younger diners prioritize price first, while Baby Boomers focus more on portion stability, freshness, and flavor. Interestingly, two in five consumers believe that if something feels too cheap, there’s likely a quality tradeoff, creating a strategic sweet spot for operators. Beyond the food itself, service quality and dining environment play significant roles, with over 80% saying these experiential factors boost their perception of value, according to Datassential.
Which restaurant types offer the best value according to consumers?

Fast food restaurants rank first for value perception, thanks to predictable pricing structures, combo meal options, and strong brand recognition around affordability. Home cooking comes in second place, followed by fast casual restaurants, grocery prepared foods, and then full-service dining establishments. Grocery prepared foods have emerged as a serious competitor in the food-away-from-home landscape, offering both convenience and affordability while avoiding the perceived “restaurant tax” that diners associate with eating out.
What types of deals and promotions do restaurant customers want most?

The most appealing promotions across all generations are percentage-off discounts, combo meals, buy-one-get-one (BOGO) offers, and buy-more-save-more deals. However, promotional preferences differ by age group. Gen Z gravitates toward deals that increase quantity or add extra items to their order, while Baby Boomers prefer straightforward price reductions. Recent behavior shows that 62% of consumers ordered a combo or value bundle in the past month, and 55% used a coupon or loyalty reward—though most used these tools only once or twice rather than constantly, according to Datassential.
How do restaurant operators view value compared to consumers?

There’s a notable gap between operator strategy and consumer behavior. Operators overwhelmingly believe consumers define value as “high-quality food that’s worth the price,” with only 5% thinking customers want purely the cheapest option. While 92% of operators say delivering value is a core priority and 83% feel confident in their pricing strategy, most acknowledge it’s harder than ever to maintain value perception without impacting margins. The disconnect: consumers theoretically agree that quality and experience define value, but their actual purchasing behavior still leans heavily on discounts and promotions — which operators often view as secondary strategies.
What are the most effective value strategies restaurants are using in 2025?

According to Datassential, nearly three-quarters of operators recently introduced or relaunched value-focused strategies . The most common and effective approaches include daily specials, combo meals, loyalty rewards programs, limited-time offers, happy hour deals, and complimentary extras. These strategies succeed because they pair craveable menu items with transparent, easy-to-understand pricing. Operators report that the key ingredients for successful value initiatives are simple pricing structures, easy kitchen execution, and strong cross-utilization of ingredients to protect margins while delivering perceived value.
How can restaurants deliver value without hurting profit margins?

Successful operators follow several principles to balance value and profitability. First, never compromise on quality and flavor, as taste remains the top driver of dining decisions. Second, use portion sizes strategically — smaller portions can work when offset by freshness, customization options, or enhanced experience. Third, simplify all value communication with clear pricing and transparent menu language. Fourth, design flexible value vehicles like bundles, add-ons, and rotating limited-time offers. Fifth, invest in emotional value through hospitality, atmosphere, and operational consistency. Finally, stay competitive with grocery prepared foods by emphasizing what restaurants uniquely offer: flavor innovation, personalized service, and superior dining experiences.
Are consumers willing to pay more if the value is there?

Yes, consumers are willing to pay premium prices when they perceive strong value. Seventy-four percent of diners say a meal can represent excellent value even at a higher price point. Two-thirds of operators report that consumers care more about overall value than the specific number on the check, and nearly 60% believe diners evaluate service, environment, and experience—not just price — when determining value. The key is building consumer confidence that their money was well spent, which comes from transparency, quality consistency, and delivering on expectations across the entire dining experience.
What’s the biggest mistake restaurants make with value in 2025?

The biggest mistake is assuming value means cheap. Value in 2025 isn’t about offering the lowest prices — it’s about creating confidence that diners made a smart choice with their money. Operators who focus exclusively on discounting without maintaining quality, service, and experience erode long-term brand equity. The brands succeeding in 2025 master transparency in pricing, maintain consistent quality, offer simple and clear value propositions, and design craveable menu items that justify their price points. Value is built through the full dining experience, not just the bill at the end.